From: Lisa Lehman

Tin Foil ornaments (cut out cardboard shapes & wrap in foil)
Dough ornaments
Pine cone ornaments (simply paint & decorate if you wish)
Paper chains
Popcorn strings alternated with cranberry
Dried oranges and apples
Cinnamon sticks tied together with a ribbon
Bows
Decorated clothespins or popsicle sticks
Bead ornaments
Felt ornaments
Candy canes
Candy canes with pipe cleaner antlers & glued on eyes

And check Goodwill or similar stores...They always have decorations!